MS of the complete but probably unfinished work on 380 quarto leaves (pp. 1-182 of larger size than the rest), comprising 745 pages.
MS of the complete but probably unfinished work on 380 quarto leaves (pp. 1-182 of larger size than the rest), comprising 745 pages (erroneously paginated 1-735), some mutilated at edges; pp. 1-196, a fair copy of the first fourteen chapters, in one hand, that of Daniel Skinner (being almost certainly a recopying of an earlier transcript by Jeremie Picard); pp. 197-735, bearing extensive alterations and rewriting, in a second hand, that of Jeremie Picard (evidently the original copier of the whole work), but for pp. 183-96, 308, 571-4, which are entirely in Daniel Skinner's hand, with numerous recopying (of less legible portions of Picard's MS) in Skinner's hand elsewhere, sometimes on pasted-on slips in the margin (most notably on pp. 206, 222, 235, 247, 281-2, 304, 311, 328, 350, 353, 362, 381, 411, 461A, 472, 475, 486-7, 490, 506, 552, 559, 596, 617, 642, 686 [verso], 703), with additions probably in several other hands throughout; Picard's portion probably written earlier (post 1659) and Skinner's after Milton's death; the prologue (pp. 1-6) headed with a dedication to the Christian church throughout the World ([IO]ANNES MILTONVS Anglus Vniversis Christi Eccleijs...
); the work headed before the first chapter (p. 7) De Doctrina Christiana ex sacris duntaxat libris petita disquisitionum libri duo posthumi
; later pencil markings in the text by Charles Sumner made in the 19th century.
c.1659-75.
Daniel Skinner made an abortive attempt to publish this work through Elzevir in 1675, after which his father handed this MS over to Sir Joseph Williamson, Secretary of State (together with the Skinner MS
of state papers: see Introduction); it was discovered in 1823 by Robert Lemon, Deputy Keeper of the Public Records.
Edited from this MS (in translation) in Sumner, with a facsimile of the first page of Chapter I as frontispiece; collated in Columbia. Discussed in Sotheby, Ramblings, pp. 153-63, with facsimile examples; in James Holly Hanford, The Date of Milton's De Doctrina Christiana, SP, 17 (1920), 309-19; in Arthur Sewell, Milton's De Doctrina Christiana, E&S, 19 (1933), 40-66; in Maurice Kelley, This Great Argument: A Study of Milton's De Doctrina Christiana as a Gloss upon Paradise Lost (Princeton, 1941), with facsimile examples after p. 218 (illustrating what Kelley takes to be at least seven and perhaps as many as twenty different hands); in Parker, II, 1056-7; in Maurice Kelley, Considerations touching the Right Editing of John Milton's De Doctrina Christiana, with a facsimile example, in Editing Seventeenth Century Prose, ed. D.I.B. Smith (Toronto, 1972), pp. 31-50; and in Gordon Campbell, De Doctrina Christiana: Its Structural Principles and Its Unfinished State, Milton Studies, 9 (1976), 243-60; and see also Maurice Kelley's articles, The Recovery, Printing and Reception of Milton's Christian Doctrine, HLQ, 31 (1967-8), 34-41; The Composition of Milton's De Doctrina Christiana: First Phase, in Th' Upright Heart and Pure, ed. Amadeus P. Fiore (Pittsburgh, 1967), pp. 35-44; and On the State of Milton's De Doctrina Christiana, ELN, 27 (1989), 43-8. Facsimile example also in HLQ, 33 (1969-70), after p. 400. See also Introduction above, Documents Signed on Milton's Behalf, No. ix. For an interesting but unconvincing argument that this work is not by Milton and that the ascriptions in the MS may have been spuriously added later, see William B. Hunter, The Provenance of the Christian Doctrine, SEL, 32 (1992), 129-42, illustrated with facsimile examples (and see also counter-arguments by Barbara K. Lewalski and John T. Shawcross, with Hunter's reply, pp. 143-66).